I just wanted to leave a review of how awesome our dinner was tonight. We drove 15 minutes from our hotel to pick up pizzas and then ordered their blueberry/white chocolate bread pudding. It was delicious! We love finding local pizzas vs. chain places, and the added dessert was a bonus! It was definitely worth the drive. The beautiful homes were also nice to see. Thank you for sharing your culinary expertise with a great community. I wish we could have sat outside and enjoyed the ambiance as well, but we had to get back to the hotel.Sent from my iPhone
Had the worst experience ever here today. I have been getting the same pizza here forever, now they can't make it because they don't know how to charge for adding ranch instead of sauce. The manager was not professional at all. Definitely lost a customer
Tonight was my the first time in since they moved from the Fairview (didn't know they were in the new place until last night). I made a dine in order 617pm and sat down. 10 to 7 I went to the counter and asked about my order and an associate brought it out, boxed to go. When I told him it was a dine in there he just asked "You want me to get you some plates?", no apology for their mistake, no offer to remake the food which had been cooling in boxes for at least 20 minutes, no apparent concern at all. I just took the food, told him I wasn't impressed with what happened to which he just shrugged and walked away. So now, instead of enjoying a nice night out enjoying good atmosphere and food, I'm at home eating reheated pizza (the cheesesticks did not microwave well and were tossed) and wondering how long it'll be before I go back again.
They have amazing cakes! We got a strawberry cake for our child's birthday today and it was so good! Fresh strawberries in the icing. Staff is great!
The interior has a rather stark, industrial-looking interior but the food is good. We had house salads which had lettuce, olives, cheese, tomato, and white onion. The orange vinaigrette dressing is excellent. The pizza's crust is crispy and not tough. The toppings are generous. I rated it four stars because the service was spotty. Our server disappeared for long periods and then would suddenly reappear when the other server started to wait on us.
Very quaint local hole in the wall eatery. Friendly, attentive staff, many vegan options. My only suggestion would be have a meatless sauce for the Sunday pasta night.
Very nice pizza, sandwichs, baked goods and desserts using organic ingredients in an ultra clean environment and in a beautiful setting in an upscale side of town - near downtown and in the Old Cloverdale Historical District.
Tripadvisor has the wrong address for Tomatino's, it is located at: 503 Cloverdale Rd, Montgomery, AL 36106
Best Pizza in Montgomery.
Charged us 30$ for a Supreme pizza and Charged us 1.75 for a can drink they didn't have no straws we had 3 kids with us to high gave my husband a half of cup of coffee 4$ no refills. No going back. Just enough topping to cover the bread