Johnny Brusco's New York Style Pizza

2415 Moores Mill Rd Suite 200, Auburn - 36830
111 reviews
Pizza Italian
(334) 826-0535

This restaurant is so underrated. The pizza is so good and for a great price. It is good both eating at the restaurant and taking it to-go. I have been here many times and will keep going.

Wonderful food and great service!

Great food and service had the Stromboli and salad

They never seem to have your order ready. Even if you order an hour and a half early. They are completely unapologetic for it as well.

Great people, great service, great food, we keep going back.

I frequent Johnny’s on Moores Mill often. They changed ownership a few years ago and the difference has been huge. The pizza, calzones, stromboli are all excellent (great dough!) and I also like the beef wrap quite a bit. The restaurant doesn’t have a ton of seating so during rushes, there can be a wait but that’s actually an endorsement. They have a lot of repeat customers, and for a reason. Give it a try. I’m confident that you will be glad you did.

We ordered two medium pizzas to go our first trip there we ordered one meat pizza and a margherita pizza. They were both good..Second time we ordered the same pizzas and asked for them to be crispy with extra cheese. They came out perfect, we finished our pizzas before making it back to Montgomery. Which is why we came back a third time. We ordered the same pizzas extra cheese crispy, the crust was scorched. We couldn't enjoy it because of the scorched crust and bubbly scorched cheese.. we are wanting to go back but if the guy that made them the first 2 trips is not there we do not want anyone else to make them..

Still waiting for our food at our table….short staffed and take out orders the priority per server. Hmmmmm, picked up a take out order a few weeks ago and waited another 20 minutes after the first 30 minutes. Last visit - better pizza and service in many other places in Auburn.

Got a calzone yesterday that was okay, but certainly not a classic calzone. Switched to a Stromboli today and had same kind of experience- nothing to bag on, but edible, though dough was a bit undercooked. And the marinara was still an abomination with green peppers in it.

Two times now. First was carry out that we had to wait extra cause they forgot one pizza snd then got home it was wrong. This time eating in and got here before 5PM and is now 6 Pm and still waiting for food. No they are not crowded.