Pizzaiolo - The Pizza Maker's Pizza

37 Eglinton Ave E, Toronto - M4P 1A1
45 reviews
Pizza Vegan Gluten-Free
(416) 482-2000

I ordered from these guys the other day. They said 30 minutes. I drove over to their young st location. As I pulled up the called me. Sorry we’re out of dairy free cheese. Who waits 25min to figure out they can’t fulfill the order?

amazing pizza. great choice

I always like their pizzas! They have a really yummy smell which pills us from the walkway! Especially this location!

Ordered pizzas and there was virtually no cheese on it. If it's a cost saving tactic I would highly encourage this store to reconsider their business model. Thick soggy dough. Yuk! Overpriced and subpar service (took over 1.15 hours for a pickup when app said 35 mins) . I will not be eating here again. Sorry.Update: I reached out to customer service who never responded. I can see that this business has deep rooted customer service problems.

I loved their pizza, different from others.Base is good. Close to authentic

I really like the smell of these place's pizzas!!! I don't even mention about the taste. ? Clean store and so friendly staff.! Recommend these delicious meal for anyone ??

This store does not use any cheese on their pizza. The pizza was cold and the crust was so thick and soft, it was undercooked. I just read the other reviews and OMG they are so true. My pizza had virtually no cheese on it. Isn't that one of the main things on a pizza? My pizza was so bad my family did not eat it and we ended up getting another take out.

By far the WORST pizza I've ever had. Cold, burnt and without cheese. We ordered the Mediterranean and Capone and both were so cheap. Pizza hut does a better job making pizzas, than this shop. Also, very overpriced. Never getting pizzas from here again.

I walk by this place to and from work every day and the smells from here kept drawing me in... FINALLY had a soccer last night and the pizza was good! Not as amazing as I expected (probably because I hyped it up so much in my head) but very good pizza. The crust was nice and crispy without being burnt or oily. It was probably one of the better crusts I have had on a NY style pizza.

The quality has gone downhill over the past few years. Used to be the best pizza in Milton. Now it’s dry and never enough toppings or cheese!!! I ordered EXTRA cheese this time just to make sure they put enough, and still I could barely taste it. So little there were plenty of bare spots on the pizza where it was just dough and a bit of sauce. Totally sucks cause it used to be so delicious. Second time in a row that it was terrible. Won’t be ordering from them again. And SO incredibly expensive for what you get. Super super disappointed.