Miller Tavern

31 Bay St., Toronto - M5J 3B2
89 reviews
Steak House Seafood
(416) 366-5544

We went here before the Raptors game, but it wasn’t too busy. Server was nice and friendly, we got seated right away. We ordered Wagyu burger and pan seared Halibut. Halibut tasted really good, especially mixing with rice and creamy sauce. Wagyu burger on the other hand was kind the disappointing. Although it looked really good, it tasted very bland and lacked much flavour. I should’ve went with the other burger.

Attended this restaurant with a client of mine before the Leafs game 1 of the playoffs for the first time. I was pleasantly surprised. The food, service and establishment were top notch!I think my favourite part about our experience here was the attention we received not only from our server but from other servers and staff asking to take plates, if we needed refills and if just asking if everything was ok. We were also greeted by the Manager Michael who was such a gentlemen! Had a brief conversation with him and could tell why he was the manager! Very nice guy! Our server was Tyler, shout out to him cause he was fantastic! Knew the menu well, had extensive knowledge with the food and drinks which he offered us at every turn. We chatted throughout our meal about random things as well and my client and I both thought he was such a nice guy! Looking forward to seeing you again Tyler. It was a pleasure!The food! Awesome…. We started with some drinks, the escargot and the charcuterie board. They were both amazing and we ate every last bite. The bread they serve with both of them just topped it off. Next we had the butchers steak with Cesar salads. The steaks were cooked perfectly, seared on the outside but nice and tender and juicy on the inside. Makes my mouth water as I am typing this lol. The Caesar, very lemony and full of flavour! A very good side dish for the steak.After dinner we had some Martinis, tequila shots and some more banter with Tyler and we were off to the game! Congrats staff and restaurant on providing my client and I an excellent experience. I will be back with other clients as it was a great look for me bringing him here! Cheers Michael, Tyler and staff!

Went during lunch on an off-day. The place not only has a great interior aesthetic, but the service and food were on point. It was a little pricier than I had originally anticipated (specially for lunch) but logically this makes sense because of the location and the quality of food. Would highly recommend and will probably come here again some point within the future.

We followed the reviews prior to our visit, but ended up dissatisfied with our meal/experience.Our 2 guests had to swap steaks because they did not arrive as ordered (medium rare and medium) - one was served well done (dry) and the other was rare. Our guests did not return the order as the waiter appeared hurried and was not overly helpful. I ordered fries with my steak and received a salad instead.The halibut entree was very small (appetizer size) and not fresh - neither were the 2 appetizers we had ordered - they appeared to be warmed over from frozen. Given the prices here we expected fresh food.The casesar salad was good.Not very pleased at all, including the tip the bill was over $430.00.

Slightly pricey for just a quick bite before our concert. However, quite possibly the best burger I have ever had. So delicious! Also very good service.

Beef and Tuna TartareTruffle Lobster Mac and CheeseLobster club with parm friesPalate cleanser ProseccoIncredible service from Mike, highly recommend going here and if you are so lucky and Mike is in, ask for him!The vibe is calm and relaxing, Rob the Bar Manager kept checking in to make sure we were happy as well, all around a great experience and we will be back!

Just had the most amazing experience at the Miller Tavern they accommodated a dairy allergy right from the start all the way to the end of the dining experience. Our server Justin was nothing short of spectacular very knowledgeable and helpful with everything on the menu. The rib-eye steaks were to die for. Highly recommended the brussel sprouts and hand picked green salad. Can't stress this enough of how awesome Justin was. What ever you're paying that man double it.

We were a large group of more than 15 people. So they provided us with a space/ room for to accommodate our group. The room was extremely cold, we informed the staff and they did nothing about it.The food arrived late, it wasn't good for the price we paid. Both my husband and sister had nausea after food, my sister did not even finish her burger. They made a mistake with my order. The steak was not cooked properly, the fries were oily and you could taste the old oil in it...It is unacceptable to pay more than 74$ for a steak that is not properly done with old fries, cold place and don't know how to take orders properly - which is a simple task.

Food was pretty great and the bartender and server were also great. The restaurant itself is getting pretty warn down - torn up furniture and stuff. I booked the reservation through open table and confirmed that when entering, but they cancelled it so I wouldn't get the open table points. Not sure why they did that, but it has bothered me a bit..

Went in for drinks as it was close to our hotel and the hotel bar was not open. Glad we did. The bartender was very welcoming and friendly. Would be a good place to watch a game. We did not eat but did see a lot of food coming out of the kitchen and it looked very good and smelled even better. Next time we go we will definitely be eating.