Pickle Barrel

17215 Yonge St, Newmarket - L3Y 5L8
93 reviews
Canadian Cocktail Bar
(905) 235-7444

Food was good, prices decent for the whole meal. Our server was very nice, but the service was a little slow.

Not a bad spot. It has nice decor inside and the patio outside is beautiful! The menu has some potential and has lots to choose from. I had the PB Cheeseburger and the meat was a little dry. It also lacked flavour. I couldn’t pinpoint it but something else was needed to really bring out the flavour of the patty. Also had the PB Pan Nachos. Plenty of nachos for 3 people. We added the beef chili and again, just lacked flavour. The chili was bland and the salsa wasn’t what I had hoped for. I’d go again but would likely order something else.

Hats off to the staff !! We had over 40 people for a birthday celebration and the service was absolutely great from the time of booking right up to the event. Our servers Brad, Taylor & Mitch were on top of everything (even with guests moving around to talk) our food was delivered in a reasonable time frame and hot. Not sure how they kept track of all the individual bills but not one mistake!! THANK YOU! Would definitely recommend!

Me and my husband have been a few times since the Covid restrictions lifted. Our recent visit was to their patio…. Food here is always great, great portions for the price. The wine was impeccable & servers warm n friendly. We complimented the dishes and their chef Garett, personally came out to give us a hug. Soo cute!! Thanks guys?

Came here with my boyfriend for our date night this week. Good service. Everything came out quick. Food was pretty good

We had a party of 40 here the other night - they were awesome! They were very accommodating - we asked if they could come up with an early bird menu for us - but serve it at 8 to 10 for our group and the manager was great. We had 2 meat choices, a pasta and 2 vegetarian choices. The staff was awesome, food was ready for us when we arrived and served around 8:15 after drinks were served. The food itself was great and hot for all!We had added an extra guest and an additional meal was prepped quickly for the person, at the same cost. The staff was terrific and we will use them again for a larger sized function like this again in the future !

For the first time me and some friends went pickle barrel recently and I would just like to mention that we had such an amazing waiter. His name was Taylor and he was very polite. He always asked us if we wanted to get refills on our water and always checked back to see how the food was. I would really love coming back and have him be our waiter!

Will never go there again!.. Health inspection is necessary. Had a party of 10 seated at a filthy table with food all over the floor. The cutlery still had food remnants on it, the table was sticky and still had food stuck to it. The place was empty so there's no excuses. Obviously this place needs a manager and to hire proper staff. This was a Saturday night and every restaurant in town was busy accept for this one..Maybe that should of been a hint. If I could give negative stars I would.

The food was sub standard. The nachos...meh...they say it's the famous ones what they ate known for but it wasn't all that. To their credit, they agreed and did charge us for it. We didn't taste any difference between the two varieties of Sandwiches we ordered.

Every time we come here, we are disappointed. Its been a year since our last visit so I figured we would give it an other shot. The hostess was busy, so the bartender had to seat us. She had a hard time smiling and didn’t bring us a kid menu. We ordered pasta for our daughter and it had zero sauce in it and her pasta was under cooked. (We order the one with the Alfredo sauce). I ordered the shrimp and lobster pasta and had literally one piece of lobster in it mixed in with under cooked pasta. It took forever to get side of sauce for my daughter pasta. Then we waited 10 minutes for a non heated cookie. Not sure why it took that long.This is the last time we will be returning to this restaurant. Every time we come here we are disappointed with the service is always less than mediocre.