Papillon Pizzeria

16610 Bayview Ave Unit 1&2, Newmarket - L3X 2H9
61 reviews
Pizza
(905) 235-0900

This pizza is really great. I find it frustrating that so many average or worse pizza places exist. Tasted amazing, crust was soft, chewy, yet crispy. If you are reading reviews considering making an order? ya just do it, this pizza is fire.

This was delicious pizza! It was thin but sturdy and it was great quality and tasted fresh. Definitely a step up from ordinary takeout pizza. Will definitely return.

We ordered from here for father's day and firstly we have to say that the pizza was excellent! The crust was very good and the ingredients were good. They were not stingy with the toppings. They also had very fast and organized service. I knew when my food was being prepared, ready, and being delivered. The driver was super nice. The last few times we ordered from chain/commercial pizza places we've been disappointed, and so it's great to find a local spot that makes good quality pizza with great service!

I ordered the x-large pepperoni walk-in special. The dough was light with a thorough coating of cheese to the edge of the crust. The crust was light and flavourful. I can't wait to try one of their specialty pizzas on a future visit.

Ordered from here a few times when I had a team working on my deck. Great food for a physically demanding day. Love the fried dishes are packed with air holes so onion rings and fried mushroom still stayed crispy. Chicken wings reminded me of classic pubs. Straight deep fried then lots of sauce on top. The skin was very crispy. A bit chewy.Brings back memories for me from those college bar nights lol… but if you want tender wings then definitely avoid them. Garlic knots were soft and flavourful. Pizza was a bit salty to my taste but I’m more on the light side anyway. Overall not a every day place for me. But definitely will come back for days when I crave for some not so healthy food ?

Easily the best pizza in York Region. Have been enjoying Papillon weekly for a number of months now and their pizzas are consistently delicious. High quality ingredients and attention to detail come through in the taste of their product. It's as close to New York pizza as you will get outside of New York. Unfortunately I don't have a picture to share as my attention is usually more on eating the pizza and less on taking photographs of it :) Try Papillon and you'll never look back.

had heard good things , all true.We love pizza , but it has to be "good" pizza.Have a wood fired oven at home I can make some quality pie.The Papillion New York style is a winner.Awesome crust and sauce.the new go to for takeout

Great pizza and great service. Crust is the perfect balance of crispy and chewy, sauce is tasty, and toppings are fresh and generous. There might be better pizza in Newmarket, but I haven't tasted it.

Excellent service and delicious pizza ?Also good prices and features option for dinner

I ordered 2 large pizzas yesterday through skip the dishes. When they arrived one was smaller than the other. I was upset thinking I received a medium but was charged for 2 large. I gave a thumbs down and bad review on skip the dishes, and only then contacted Papillon about the issue. They clarified that one of the pizzas came out larger than the other and because they didnt want to bend it in a large pizza box, they put it in an Xlarge box. I felt bad and tried to reverse the negative review on skip the dishes but they can't do that (which is ridiculous). Anyway, Papillon Pizza deserves an apology on my end. I wish I could reverse the thumbs down on that App (which should get the negative review, in my mind now). The only thing I wasn't particularly fond of was the flavours of the veggie and mediterranean pizzas; that's where the 4 stars comes in. Sorry Papillon Pizza for the misunderstanding.