The Italian Eatery

90 Park Pl Blvd, Barrie - L4N 8V4
117 reviews
Italian
(705) 733-2697

Had a great experience here. Enjoyed browsing their shelves of interesting items. Tried their lasagna and their delicious cannolis. Friendly people and great food. Will be back.

This was my first time in The Italian Market. Rose was absolutely wonderful at educating me about their products and went above and beyond to give tips on how I can arrange my items in the gift basket safely. My son and I returned for some delicious Gelato (first timers again) before heading home and we were quite impressed. Thank you for your generous hospitality!!

Loved the food at Italian Eatery and service is excellent. Friendly people and the patio is really warm and relaxing to eat on the spot.

I’ve sampled various items from this establishment.The latest we’re beyond stale biscotti, a custard tart that was the consistency of mashed potatoes. Let’s not mention the permanent scowl on the owner/managers face. She’s rude on the best of days and her manners have gone out the window. Clearly not a true Italian….The pizza is decent and they have a good selection of boxed items hard to find elsewhere. Too bad the service and quality of baked goods is hit and miss.

Terrible food found not one but two hairs in my sandwich. Called owner and he took no responsibility for this. Instead told me I was rude for referring to him as the bald guy at the counter. Did not care about the hair at all. Stay away if you care about cleanliness. I referred to him as the bald guy because I don't know his name and he has no hair. My guess is it's all in his sandwiches.

I come here all the time for dinner when I’m craving Italian. Calamari is our go to appetizer. Their Alfredo pasta is my favourite. And can never go wrong with their desserts. My family and I did not like the mussels but they have great customer service and said they would replace it for us. Order also comes with garlic knots.

We were super excited to see all the various groceries, from noodles to pizza. The cannoli we purchased was pistachio and it was delicious. It will be a place we shop more frequently from now on.

We had the Italian eatery cater our sons confirmation this past weekend . What an amazing experience from start to finish. The food…. Our expectations were blown out of the water . Not only was it delicious, but the portions were very generous and they prices are super reasonable . I would highly recommend them to everyone . You will not be left disappointed ! The have gained a customer for life

Pizza... Amazing. Spaghetti and meatballs... Amazing. Chicken saltimbocca... Amazing. Chicken alfredo... Amazing.They even tossed in some bread for us to try, but we're so full that we can't even take another bite.We'll definitely be back!

This eatery was recommended to me by someone who knew I liked veal sandwiches and was a regular at California Kitchen. I decided to give them aa try. I was expecting a simply eatery but was surprised that it is also a mini Italian market with a good selection of items for the Italian loving palate. The sweets looked good as well and I'll be back to check them out and give them a review. My sandwich was served on a long rather than round bun. While it was good, it was not excellent. I felt like I was eating more bread than meat. The sandwich was a little light on the sauce and not as hot as I expected, especially when i had ordered an extra hot sandwich. Its priced at $10 which is lower than the $12 at California Kitchen. However, I think the latter sandwich is worth the extra $2. I would recommend giving them a try as my friend liked it enough to recommend them to me. I'll be back to taste some more of their offerings. This review and rating is for the veal sandwich only.